Body mass index (BMI) may not measure obesity accurately

Posted by: admin on: July 19, 2011

BMI is a highly insensitive measure of obesity prone to under-diagnosis, while direct fat measurements are superior because they show distribution of body fat.

  • In a single-center study, 66% of patients classified as obese on the basis of DEXA scanning had BMI values in the non-obese range, according to Eric Braverman, MD, of New York Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center.
  • Among more than 1,000 patients, 56% were obese according to the DEXA results, versus 20% using the standard BMI-based definitions.
  • Scoffing at BMI as the “baloney mass index,” Braverman said it’s “very likely that obesity is a much bigger epidemic than the 300 million people acknowledged by the World Health Organization.”
  • BMI is just a mathematical equation based solely on height and weight that is too general for diagnosing anything, especially in such an exacting field of clinicians.
  • Braverman said that if any endocrinologists rely on math to calculate thyroid stimulating hormone, he would be laughed at.
  • DEXA scans, on the other hand, provide a direct measurement of body fat percentage and can spot fat exactly, in every part of the body.
  • It’s particularly effective, Braverman said, for that part of the population that is known as “thin-but-unfit.”
  • Their condition is known as normal-weight obesity, in which the BMI is low but they have a high percentage of body fat, especially compared with more favorable tissue like muscle.
  • These patients are at higher risk of dyslipidemia, as well as hypertension among men and cardiovascular disease among women.
  • The researchers found that DEXA identified 56% of patients as obese while BMI identified 20% as such.
  • Among those classified as obese by DEXA, only 34% were classified as obese by BMI and 5% of patients identified as obese by BMI actually weren’t obese according to DEXA scans.
  • These individuals were muscular and large, so they look like they’re high weight but they really had high muscle mass.
  • This means that we may have more health problems, as individuals are delaying treatment because they don’t think they’re obese and think they’re thin and ‘just a little flabby.

http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2010/05/body-mass-index-bmi-measure-obesity-accurately.html

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

CMHF Accredited by Maharashtra Medical Council

Subscribe to our Posts

Enter your email address:



  • drchasrani: Difficult to get such a data, authenticated at that. Try Times of India online library
  • rakesh pore: hi, where can i get genuine information about "10 most common drugs sold in india?" i want it for a local project
  • nilesh dutta: sir, Plz give detail about MBA Sports Management Thanks and Regards

Events

  • No events

Calculate Your Body Mass Index



Check your Body Mass Index »

    Hazelnuts - 650 kcal in 100g
    650kcal
    Hazelnuts - 650 kcal in 100g
    by Noni

Calendar

July 2011
M T W T F S S
« Jun   Aug »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031